|
Radiant heating offers the optimum in climate control comfort by conditioning the environment with radiant warmth, such as experienced by walking into the warmth of the sunlight on a cool day. In a room, we can create this warming effect with radiant panels and offset the radiant cold from outside walls and windows. The issues of people comfort as related to the radiant heating process are addressed in the ASHRAE engineering manuals in great detail. If you are a project designer, architect, engineer, or building a new home or adding or re-modeling your present home, contact us for some specifics on what our products and services can do for you or your client. As you read along, you will sense that we have been involved in many different types of project applications and have a broad range of experience in applying the radiant system to just the project that you have in mind. Let us look over your drawing so that we can share ideas. ASHRAE literature notes that comfort is achieved by either increasing the "ambient" temperature or by raising the "mean radiant" temperature of an environment. A higher radiant temperature means that people become comfortable with a lower ambient temperature and the reverse is also true. Therefore - raising the radiant temperature of an environment achieves comfort with a lower ambient temperature. This is a substantial saving to energy consumption and fuel costs. The radiant heating process saves energy and also supplies a better quality of comfort. People comfort is achieved when people are - directly or by re-radiation - in the "shine" of the radiant source. Our program focuses on achieving this goal! In the July 1996 issue of the ASHRAE JOURNAL, there is an interesting article by two ASHRAE engineers from the technical advisory committee on energy conservation, showing wall panel radiant heating to be 33% more efficient than heat pumps and 52% more efficient than standard baseboard heaters. Like a copy? Drop me an e-mail and give me some details of your project and I'll be glad to send it along. Through the years there have been a variety of radiant systems developed. Frank Lloyd Wright utilized radiant heat in the floors via hot water back in the 40's. Older buildings and schools still use some form of hot water heating. However in these systems thermal lag (the time between start-up and comfort - or cool down and no heat) is far too long, and energy wastes are excessive. Owners had high fuel wastes - their clients had poor comfort - either too hot or too cold. Energy waste is excessive during the mild seasons - therefore fuel wasting occurs during MOST of the year. So - for most of the heat conditioning time (most of us live in mild temperature zones for a big portion of the year) - it was POOR COMFORT and BIG FUEL WASTES! When heating fuel costs were inexpensive, lag losses and/or transmission losses (the heat lost within a structure by transporting hot water or warm air past cold walls or through ducts) were not an issue that owners worried about. In today's energy market where energy costs are substantial and escalating rapidly, fuel costs can have a serious effect on owners' profits (see why comfort and energy efficiency are poor in the - heater placement - section of the site). Ceiling electric panels were sometimes used.These offer poor and spotty comfort. Most of the radiant energy is very directional and the comfort is absorbed by the floor and carpet. The panel area is insufficient for a satisfactory wash of radiant shine. Installers sought to overcome this problem by adding more panels than required to satisfy the heat loss. This caused heating fuel wastes and resulted in high energy bills. So we were back to high fuel costs and poor comfort (see why comfort and energy efficiency are poor in the - heater placement - section of the site). It ought to be clear that the radiant heat source location and placement is directly related to the effectiveness of the people comfort factor and the energy efficiency. Our 20 + years of experience with a wide variety of commercial and residential applications, can help you achieve BOTH energy efficiency and comfort.
You mentioned health and its relation to radiant heating could you elaborate briefly? We noted that the radiant heating process was a "natural" heating process since it simulated the radiant warming process of the sun. Individuals are affected by radiant warmth either through direct "shine" exposure or by re-radiation from surrounding objects. This means people are comfortable when in an environment of a sufficient quantity of radiant energy or as ASHRAE puts it, when the mean radiant temperature is increased to offset any cold radiating surfaces, such as windows and exterior walls. The higher the radiant temperature the lower the ambient temperature. The secret to energy conservation with the radiant cove and wall panel heating is, a lower ambient temperature with a higher radiant temperature coefficient, using a well developed energy management controller, means better comfort, less fuel consumption, and significantly lower energy costs. Another important consideration of the radiant heating process is the fact that warmth is achieved without passing air through ducts or water-type humidifiers. This is extremely important to people who are aware of the effects to their health of poor air quality. Ducts and humidifiers are prime breeding grounds for many types of bacteria. Pollution from gas burn-off, dirty ducts and contaminated water in heat exchangers are directly linked to the health problems confronting individuals turning "on" their heating system for the first time of the season. Groups of individuals have experienced "mysterious" respiratory and other more serious problems in hotels, hospitals, and schools that seem unexplainable, other than from bacteria in air ducts or heat exchangers and/or polluting gasses. BUT, it appears that poor air quality relates to discomfort and distress for many people. Ergonomics is the study of environmental conditions that relates to people stress and health. I have recently met, through these pages, an engineer with 40 years of experience dealing with air pollution and air distribution problems, who has an internationally recognized reputation in all phases of commercial, industrial, and institutional applications, specifically problems relating to health and air quality, and has worked closely with many ergonomists. His background offers a unique perspective on this subject. He gave his gracious permission to use his address for your questions. His e-mail wmcmichael@ns.gemlink.com could offer important information for your evaluation process from an air quality viewpoint. Health officials are increasingly aware that indoor air quality and non-polluting systems are meaningful considerations in selecting a heating program, especially if elderly clients are in consideration. Quality heating is the most important part of the climate conditioning for every project. People require heat during most of the year and it's irritating to be chilly and uncomfortable during these months. Heating ought to be the finest in comfort and energy efficiency that is available.
You also mentioned the term natural - What about these points:
1) thermal characteristics of the human body as
related to comfort and radiant heating , 2) the radiant comfort
process and people working together in various levels of activity?
Mr. Hall has written several books on this subject. The quoted comments
speak to the essence and importance of radiant heating and its
relationship to the ability of humans to be responsive to the
characteristics of the radiant factor as it relates to comfort and
health of people. Recent publications, have addressed these issues in
great depth. People comfort becomes increasingly essential for work
productivity and reducing stress loads and in the home, for improved
quality of living.
How can insulation characteristics effect comfort and energy efficiency within the radiant heating process? Since I am not an expert on insulation, I have quoted from some authors that have studied the insulation process. Their results will certainly have interest to those contemplating the development of a new building or a retrofitting project. The objective of insulation is to protect the indoor environment from outside temperatures, hot or cold. Is this protection over-hipped by the insulation manufacturers and is there other important considerations in this protection process that are as least as important - well let's look into this and see what is truly needed for your project. Mr. Jay McGrew, President of Applied Science & Engineering Corporation, wrote an article on the value of insulation vs. the heat loss within a structure caused by other more important causes.
The above study was performed on a variety of homes in the Denver area using, " sophisticated monitoring equipment to find out precisely what happens to energy consumption within the home." I wish I could say that there has been a lot of recent insulation research that disputes the above findings, but I have not found anything as carefully monitored or more conclusive. The subject of infiltration, Dr. McGrew calls "rivers of air" is the most interesting part of the study for the radiant heating program and strengthens the importance and value of the process.
The most important points might be summarized as follows; 1) the radiant heating process heats without moving air, eliminating a vast portion of the energy wastes that is attributable to infiltration and infiltration is greatly increased by the blowers and flues connected to furnaces, water heaters, and exhaust fans, 2) the insulation process is found to be of lesser value that formerly reported, and even less important to the radiant heating process, since correct heater placement provides a radiant barrier between the cold surfaces of the walls and windows and the individuals in the environment, providing comfort in spite of the insulation. With air type heating, heat is"piled-up" on the ceiling and then drifts or stacks until the floor area is comfortable. The radiant heating process does not stratisfy warmth and it could be cooler on the ceiling than on the floor. These features add to your comfort and reduce your energy consumption.
Now, let's look into what is really important to the enhancement of radiant heating efficiency and comfort. Radiant barriers provide great reflectiveness for effective heating and cooling. Using radiant barriers will allow the owner to have the best of both worlds, better comfort for heating and cooling and better energy efficiency! Combined with a plastic wrap to reduce structural infiltration, one can experience efficient comfort in the coldest of weather. Additional fiberglass insulation will only cost more money without the enhanced benifits of infiltration protection and establishing a radiant reflective barrier, that is imperative to any heating program. Keeping heat either in or out of a structure can be a challenge. The use of radiant barriers will allow us to achieve our goals of better comfort and better energy efficiency, and be cost-effective. In an article by Mr. Philip Fairley, a research scientist at the Florida Solar Energy Center, references are made to the value of radiant barriers, primarily from a cooling stand point. The implications of his remarks, and my experiences over the years with reflective surfaces and their relationship to room heat loss, leads into some thoughts that may be meaningful to the planning of your next project.
The remarks noted above suggest that heat gain and loss within a structure are influenced by more important conditions than fiberglass insulation. I have found after many installations in all types of commercial and residential applications, that reflectiveness has a stronger influence on comfort and energy efficiency than the R-values of the insulation installed in the structure.
Let's discuss the heating and energy management for your next project and we can share some ideas on insulation.Let me illustrate with a couple of examples: (the complete details are available for your review)
How can we achieve the optimum performance from the radiant heating process using your management system? Radiant Systems Enterprises incorporates the effectiveness of low density metal cove and wall panels, energized by electricity. Electricity is the perfect energy source for radiant heating because it has no transmission or thermal losses. It is also simple to thermostatically control each heating station and to systematically control an entire project with an energy management control product. Predicted fuel escalation projections make electricity the fuel source for now and into the future throughout most of the U.S. Our performance records show favorable cost savings over hot water, forced air systems, fired by oil or natural gas, water or air type heat pumps, and other types of electric furnaces and baseboard units. These performance results were achieved through the use of our energy management control system product, designed to fulfill the requirements outlined by ASHRAE.. Let's look at this!
The formula for predicting annualized energy costs from the ASHRAE
literature - simply stated - B.T.U. loss x Degree Days x Hours of use
divided by (localized ) Temperature difference x a fuel efficiency
factor x a B.T.U. energy unit factor = quantity of fuel x fuel cost
annualized fuel costs. The entire formula hinges on the effective use of the fuel source! ASHRAE gives specific points for the energy management process if fuel efficiency is to be realized. We will review the exact specifics in the details + section of our site. The more effective use of fuel - the lower the energy cost and the more owners save. ASHRAE guidelines require that an energy management program must eliminate heating wastes caused by :
All control systems must also be responsive to changing outdoor temperatures in order to adequately respond to changing heat loss requirements. Ought to be simple? - well, we think it is! Radiant Systems Enterprises developed a control product for use by the motel industry over 15 years ago. With field testing and modifications in dozens of installations throughout the US, our energy performance results show that our product:
Our control system incorporates all of the features required by ASHRAE for effective energy management
How does heater placement and radiant "shine" relate directly to comfort, since properly placed units produce the optimum in direct and indirect radiation and therefore maximizing comfort and energy efficiency?
As the below picture illustrates radiation can be hidden and very Simply stated - Proper placement - quality products - well defined and designed energy management and modular controls, offers the owner: 1) good air quality, 2) the very best in owner controlled and automated energy management, 3) the maximum in comfort, and 4) easily installed, low maintenance heating products.
Can you tie together the correct radiant source placement and heater location for comfort and efficiency, with the available radiant heating products? And, Can any one product do the job for every type of application?
The effectiveness of the radiant heating process is predicated on even distribution of the radiant "shine" to supply the necessary amount of radiant energy to make people comfortable. As we have seen in the quoted articles in the details section, the word comfort means many different things to different individuals, considering that people have varied needs depending on their work or play activity or the lack of it. The radiant process has extremely wide possibilities for meeting people-comfort requirements. Air heating processes, either from fin-tube, unit ventilators, or forced air systems are definitely very limited, satisfying a narrow band of activity levels, and these writers are exactly right , in both their personal observations and their studied research.
The radiant designer must respond to user needs in his placement of
panels so that the product will maximize the "shine" effect. It has not On the right, we see a diagram of the cove radiant panel. I have effectively installed these units in rooms with limited ceiling heights with outstanding results in both comfort and, when installed in conjunction with our energy management control processor, high energy efficiency. These heating units and panels have a wide breadth of "shine", providing an excellent answer to raising the radiant temperature of an area. They have these features: 1) low cost, 2) no floor area use that is needed for furniture and fixture placement, and 3) extreme durablity, having a 10 year replacement warranty.
The wall radiant panels shown below, also offer an excellent radiant
sweep. I have installed these panels in a great variety of applications
with extremely effective results in comfort, and when managed by our
controller processor, they are energy efficient. The use of this
product is almost limitless. Placed near floor level, they are perfect
for residences or businesses with high ceilings. Hung from the bar
joists (12'-20 above the floor) they provide comfort, almost
unbelievably so, directly to the floor. These panels are outstanding for
use in indoor swimming pools. They are capable of sending warmth
directly to the pool water and pool deck. Carrying this forward, it is not difficult to see why people in nursing homes, assisted living residences and hospitals are not comfortable with air type heating. The necessary air movement required for the forced air heating process and fan noise places people in an environment of constant circulating drafts and irritating noise levels. The radiant losses from their bodies in an un-active living condition, are never satisfied by the cooling process of forced air heat. Supplying a high radiant comfort environment will provide the solution: 1) quiet, draft-free living conditions that, 2) can adjust to their radiant body losses. In schools, offices, and homes where people work and play with varying radiant body losses, differing comfort needs must be available. People that are temporarily ill, women having their monthly period, people exercising, or resting, or under job related tension, can all be addressed successfully through a properly designed radiant environment. Simply stated - proper placement - quality products - well defined and designed energy management and modular controls, offer the owner: 1) good air quality, 2) the very best in owner controlled and automated energy management, 3) the maximum in comfort, and 4) easily installed, low maintenance heating products.
Energy efficiency and the radiant heating process is well documented in ASHRAE engineering manuals and handbooks. Recent up-dates only confirm this to be true. Why? A simplified way of looking at this might be;
What services do you provide to make my project successful? Radiant Systems has been designing radiant heating projects since 1977, many have included air conditioning and exchange air ventilation for the owner's desires and to satisfy local building codes. Extensive commercial installations include apartments, motels, hotels, hospitals, nursing homes, assisted living residences, gymnasiums, churches, schools, multi-purpose rooms, teaching stations, camp buildings, service garages, auto and woodworking shops, indoor swimming pools, dozens of "add to" or supplemental heating to uncomfortable areas, to residential homes from 1,500 to over 10,000 square feet. Detailed information in the ASHRAE literature has been my designing guide. I know of no unsuccessful, uncomfortable, or under-designed projects that have failed to meet or exceed projected energy consumption and maintenance expectations. Few if anyone else, in the radiant business has had the opportunity to successfully design, implement, and complete such a listing of projects. The ultimate success of your project and the continuous year to year operation with efficient energy usage and low maintenance, lies in applying the following to the design process; 1) accurately calculating structural heat loss factors as related to the specific local temperature characteristics where the project is located, 2) selecting specifically, the right products for the environmental conditioning appropriate to the architectural uniqueness of the structure, 3) selective placement and installation of correctly sized equipment for reduction of energy wastes and for eliminating the poor comfort quality always associated with over sizing HVAC equipment, and 4) circuiting the electrical design to avoid excessive hardware and installation costs. Balancing these factors and years of field experience, assures an indoor environment comfortable for the user and energy efficient and cost-effective for the investor! The key ingredient for the success of the commercial and residential installations is the energy management control product developed by a team of engineers in 1980. From the comprehensiveness of the field testing and the recorded maintenance and energy performance reports, coupled with its cost effectiveness, I am very sure this system is unbeatable! This product is unlike anything else available on the market. Energy management products costing many times that of this system have produced poor energy savings, are constant maintenance problems, and very user unfriendly. Radiant heating is definitely an energy saver, as recorded in recent ASHRAE articles quoted elsewhere in this site and has proven the most comfortable and maintenance free system available, BUT for consistently high performance quality of energy efficient comfort, the process necessitates the inclusion of this energy control system! If you are a designer, architect or specifying engineer for a commercial project and feel that radiant heating could possibly advance your clients' goals, then I will assist you wherever necessary to correctly analyze and implement this process, using high quality, durable products with the energy management control system. My services extend from the design, into the bidding, construction and punch out phases of your project with NO added cost to you or the owner. I will do whatever is needed to see that your project is successful, including making accurate electrical drawings for your contractor to use on the job - WITHOUT COSTLY consulting fees. In residential projects, I have worked closely with owners, decorators, and builders to assure proper product selection, installation locations, system calibration and performance. Let's share ideas for your next project:
By Mail: Box 797 |